Anyone who has followed the debate on here about poor George Steiner's weariness of the western novel might have detected that I'm a staunch supporter of the novel per se, in all its forms, for good or ill, for better for worse, and for many reasons. Foremost perhaps because I'm not an expert, I'm not an arbiter of taste, unless you are weaning your baby that is, in which case I'd advise savoury tastes before sweet and the current evidence suggests waiting until they are six months old.
I have long felt there are as many readers for books as there are books available. Just because I'm not the right reader for a book (to snaffle Sandra at Bookworld's thinking) doesn't mean that there aren't another zillion out there who are exactly the right readers for it.
Tired narrative for me might be exciting and exhilarating for another, who's to judge? It is one great big circular debate.
For reasons various I've been pounding through John Carey's What Good are the Arts?
The last book I read by John Carey had a profound effect on my reading life to the extent that I could say it created a major turning point, confirmed what I had always felt but never quite had the courage to articulate with any confidence. The Intellectuals and The Masses : Pride and Prejudice among the Literary Intelligentsia 1880-1939 opened new trails of thought back in 2000 when I was about to embark on my year of studying modern literature.
Had all this really come about as a means of excluding the masses from culture?
Were the masses, the philistine hordes, in fact a metaphor for the unknowable and invisible?
I'm of good philistine horde stock, the nearest we got to the nineteenth-century intelligentsia was as ostlers for the Rothschilds, probably horse thieves before that which explains my love-hate thing with Equus Maximus so this was all relevant. I had a memorable year of reading with all this in mind as I tackled head on for the first time the likes of E.M.Forster, Graham Greene, T.S.Eliot, Virginia Woolf et al. I came to some interesting conclusions of my own, many of which were slowly simmered and stewed and then cemented into the foundations for the thinking behind dgr scribbles.
So I was expecting no less of a challenge to my thinking with What Good are the Arts? My version a recent edition with an added postscript from John Carey, who in the aftermath of initial publication, found himself deeply into what we might now term Archbishop territory. Misinterpreted, misquoted and generally with the literary equivalent of the Synod incandescent with rage and baying for professorial blood.
The exploration is fascinating and on the surface a seemingly simple task , do the Arts do us any good?
The methodology becomes quite complex and I almost suspect that even John Carey didn't realise quite what a maze he was traversing until he found himself slap bang in the middle of it. But though the argument often became quite convuluted for me, John Carey as you'd expect, hacks his way out the other side.
We lost each other on several occasions when I was convinced we should head one way through the maze and he steadfastly moved on in the opposite direction.It was of course me who hit the blind alleys and the dead ends and John who was carrying the picnic and had eaten all the egg sandwiches before I arrived.
But the book merits perseverance to the second section where John Carey argues 'The Case for Literature' and why he sees it as 'superior to the other arts, and can do things they cannot do.' He is keen to acknowledge and emphasise, on the back of the first half of the book, the seeming contradiction.
'...all judgements made in this part, including the judgement of what 'literature' is, are entirely subjective.'
Then proceeding to a subjective definition of literature,
'...writing that I want to remember - not for its content alone...but for itself : those particular words in that particular order. Like all criticism of art or literature my judgements are camouflaged autobiography, arising from a lifetime's encounters with words and people that are mostly too complicated to unravel.'
You see that's exactly what I think, and perhaps what many of you think too, in which case there are treasures to be unearthed for one and all in this book.
What I now think of happily as Carey-isms abound,how about this,
'Literature gives you ideas to think with. It stocks your mind. It does not indoctrinate, because diversity, counter-argument, reappraisal and qualification are its essence. But it supplies the materials for thought...it encourages questioning and self-questioning.'
or this
'Poetic ideas do not tell you what the truth is, they make you feel what it would be like to know it.'
I've taken all these out of the context and barely touched on the full argument, but I hope it may be enough to point you in the direction of this amazingly thought-provoking book. My copy of The Intellectuals and the Masses is itself a tatty, well-thumbed philistine-like mass of luminous highlighter pen markings, from the days when I used such things and life in my forties demanded it.
Now I'm into my fifties it all feels a bit less urgent, less strident, the gentler 4B pencil does very nicely, but it's been working overtime on What Good are the Arts?
Likewise Ice Land by Betsy Tobin published by Short Books has done exactly the same. Surprisingly The Daily Telegraph rarely seems to review books I've read these days except for this one and Sinclair McKay makes a good point. When a writer sets off into this territory it really can all go horribly wrong very quickly
It hardly seems like cricket to wave a book at everyone and then say how brilliant it is knowing that there seem only to be about six copies available in the world. Add this to the list and start hunting at jumble sales, charity shops and library catalogues ( not necessarily in that order ) for Dymphna Cusack.
Little Monsters has been sitting on the shelf for months in proof copy, but it took a tempting review over at
The Guardian was ferried to my bedside on Saturday morning along with the shockingly devastating news that our village shop with in-house butcher's department is closing down this week.The little Post Office is separate and will stay, but for how long?
Uppermost in my mind at the moment a book I'm halfway through, The Rowing Lesson by Anne Landsman. Oh dear, not British either but here's a bench mark book to be going on with, nothing tired or weary about this one. Anne Landsman has taken a firm grip on the throat of her narrative and is shaking it about fit to pop its eyes out.
Coffee arrived a while ago and some of those Choco-Leibniz biscuits which just insist that you nibble the chocolate off around the edges first. Anyway I'll live but my body said 'stay here under this lovely warm duvet with a cat curled up at your feet and bask' so I've had a glorious snuffly, sneezy morning reading three novels which I have in simultaneous progress.
" I must go seek some dewdrops here,
all on Friday.
it was obvious that with my current Thomas Hardy phase in full bloom the sight of these fabrics would bring on a relapse over the embargo. Doesn't that bookish writing plus oak leaf and acorn and the brown bark fabric just firmly declare Under the Greenwood Tree meets Gabriel Oak?
No not more Thomas Hardy, just the Kayaker home from Africa this week and good to see he did a bit of perch fishing while he was there. Plans to travel to friends in Tanzania by bus cut short by the unpredictable situation in the region and the difficulties of travelling anywhere fast by land with a kayak in tow. I'm hoping the cold may have killed off any wandering ants or termites in the luggage which did hold a peculiar smell all of its own. Each river returned from exudes a particular tang enhanced by longevity of wetness of gear. As always the experience has been memorable and Africa and the people amazing.
Selected Poetry and Non-Fictional Prose edited by Peter Widdowson on the shelf and determined to pick it up when I got home. Claire Tomalin's love of Hardy's poetry evident and infectious as she read several to us.
As Good as a Yarn With You edited by Carole Ferrier and published in 1992 by Cambridge University Press is a collection of correspondence between Miles Franklin, Susannah Prichard, Jean Devanny, Marjorie Barnard, Flora Eldershaw and Eleanor Dark.
Under the Greenwood Tree has been a great re-entry and I now feel quietly steeped in Thomas Hardy. I have revelled in the bucolic hilarity of the disbanding of Mellstock Village Church Quire to make way for a new-fangled harmonium, and bemoaned along with everyone else that Thomas Hardy chose not to follow this plot line through. Preferring instead to place village schoolmistress Fancy Day and her romantic involvements centre stage, Hardy had me laughing like a gawkhammer to begin with, whilst I finished the book having mumbudgetedly enjoyed a good read. There's a really helpful dialect glossary at the end of the book which has added some good new words to my daily conversation, and now I know what a dumbledore really is I can tell you that we've got loads in the garden at the moment, and they don't have white beards or wear wizard hats.
It's books like this that also remind me it will soon be the day that I head off for that first spring 'traypse and wamble' along the lanes and over the way to the village of Sydenham Dameral. Here are last year's pictures of the tiniest church but one which always feels so like those described by George Eliot in Adam Bede and Thomas Hardy here.
I think it was a fairly safe bet that I'd wallow in Hubbub : Filth, Noise & Stench in England by Emily Cockayne and soon to be published in paperback by Yale University Press. As a latter-day professional descendant of the Manchester Ladies Sanitary Reform Association of 1862 it was only to be expected.
That is until an online list chose Amongst Women as its Book of the Month for February and suddenly I remembered John McGahern all over again.
Light years ago I bought the Kristin Lavransdatter trilogy by Sigrid Undset in the certain knowledge that at £10 for these three lovely U.S. editions it would be a crime to leave them behind in the bookshop but also that I would read them one day for sure.

We have been blessed with our very own branch of Fat Face which is, to those not in the know, a nice clothing shop for Bright Young Things where it is even possible to occasionally find something for a Woman of a Certain Age. In amongst the slouchy umbilical-revealing baggy trousers and the skinny wafer thin jumpers and those smocky-style tops (I just can't bear to go back to 1973) I had found a very nice skirt before Christmas. Warm, weighty, lined fabric, nice length and style and one of the metal press stud fasteners holding the belt in place fell off about the third time I wore it.
Nice young girl who quickly assumed the mantle of
Spanish Inquisitor, fixed gaze, direct eye contact and quizzed me fiercely on how exactly I'd washed the skirt because I must have been a bit harsh on it.
I opened one book, Ice Land by Betsy Tobin published by
Now it's 5pm, the quietest of country days here, perhaps three cars have gone past all day and two of those were ours. I just made it out of bed in time for lunch and then managed to stagger to the sofa, woodburner humming away nicely and set off for Iceland again, and that's where I've spent the afternoon inbetween some therapeutic dozing.
It's taken quite a while for The Hour of the Star to sink in, settle down and for any thoughts to rise to the surface. I think it was the comparisons to Kafka that delayed me.
I've had quite a run of Jewish-Israeli reading and If You Awaken Love by Emuna Elon published by Toby Press fits snugly into this category.
Having mentioned the short story "Kew Gardens" and found my copy of Virginia Woolf's The Mark on the Wall and Other Short Fiction I had little choice. I re-read "Kew Gardens" and was immediately connected to the very essence of Virginia Woolf's writing and I wanted more.
Big thanks to Herschelian who comments here and who recommended this book for a good novel that would also furnish an even greater understanding of life and the political situation in Palestine. I bought a copy in an instant, and The Bethlehem Murders by
Leading on from this I knew there was another book that I had to read immediately. A Little Piece of Ground by Elizabeth Laird, the story of Karim, a young boy living under curfew in Ramallah and here's what Michael Morpurgo had to say about it
So having fortuitously ended up with two copies of His Illegal Self I think a Prize Draw is called for.
So along came not one but two copies of His Illegal Self (roll up later today for a free prize draw for the spare one) and cynical old me wasn't going to be impressed by a name, or browbeaten by a reputation, or even charmed by a cover bearing a beatific child fixing me with a penetratingly angelic gaze, just daring me to dislike the book...go on, just you dare...is he about to cry?
There comes a time when you just have to give in and go and buy a new one.
I had heard of
Put the kettle on, you'll need a pot of tea to get though this.
He's been desperate to read The Battle for Gullywith, looked all crestfallen when I called in without the book yesterday, and I said he couldn't have it until I'd written about it and I've been a week letting the whole experience simmer down enough to write sensibly, without going into useless over-gush, some hope.
Whilst I imagine Richard T.Kelly slapping the paint on that great big Crusaders canvas, creating a huge panoramic vista of 21st century life, I envisage
Lurking in the shadows has been The Hour of the Star by Clarice Lispector and, having read about twenty pages I knew this was a book I needed to read in one sitting if I was going to get anything from it and so I picked that up next and have just finished it. My mind is awash with the strange and bewildering read I have just had as Clarice Lispector creates her character from nothing before the reader's eyes and starts to build up a story that she constantly informs and suggests to the reader could go many ways. This is a writer bravely and candidly offering all her uncertainties for public consumption as she searches for her direction and transforms reality however she wishes.Less than a hundred pages long but an intense and concentrated lesson in the Art of Fiction.
Despite having lots of good books on the go I fancied something new and different and set about reading a "chilling dark novel of love, revenge and atonement' by Julie Parsons, I Saw You. If it was no good I had plenty of others lined up but after seventy-six pages I was gripped.
There's plenty more to qualify and enlarge on that statement but it's all robust and grounded enough to keep me interested and I have Anam Cara and Benedictus on the way. Then I feel a big Celtic phase coming on and with it that need I always have to link reading into crafts. Perhaps it's a good time to start thinking about making that little piece of Celtic applique patchwork with its eternal woven knots, interlocking curves and curlicues, no beginning and no end.
I think we are reasonably sensible level-headed cat owners, so when sister of Rocky, Tess (second right) had to go in to the vets to have a lump removed from her leg this week it seemed quite straightforward.The last animal we took in to have a lump removed was Offspringette's hamster Chippy and that cost £23 about fifteen years ago.
So HOW are we going to keep a cat indoors that lives outdoors? For ten days???
I've always moaned about the dearth of cultural events down here in the West Country. Well, alright it's not strictly true, we do have Ways With Words, but you can expect to have to travel miles to find any other events through the year.The exciting talks seem to be centred on the big cities up country and London in particular and it does my already uncertain place in heaven no good whatsoever to read something like the London Review Bookshop programme or get an invite to a Pen Pushers party. I am a vivid and emerald shade of green with envy at what is on offer for all you Londoners, does anyone else get these great pangs of covetousness or is it just me?
The stunning new Roland Levinsky arts building seemed to pop up out of nowhere, suddenly we came off the main city roundabout one day and there it was, all new and unwrapped. Named after the late and much-respected Vice-Chancellor of the university 

Recent Comments